Geobag dewatering · Laminated GCLs · Liner supply & technical supportKontain capability brochure

Kontain technical perspective · tailings management

Why smaller mines should reconsider geobag tailings storage

For mines producing 100 thousand to 1 million dry tonnes of tailings a year

Free cost comparison tool →

A geobag priced at A$7 per dry tonne buys more than a consumable. It provides a dewatering container that retains solids in their final storage position, suppresses dust from the enclosed material and reduces its direct exposure to rainfall. For a smaller mine, combining these functions can make geobags a highly competitive tailings-management option.

The comparison becomes particularly compelling when the alternative includes a filtration plant followed by cake transport, conditioning, placement and compaction. On the operating assumptions examined here, bag supply and deployment total A$9.50/dmt, compared with A$10/dmt for filtration and placement. Installed capital and the cost of operating the complete storage system can strengthen the case further.

Kontain supplies geobags, and this is our commercial and technical perspective. We recommend that mines producing 100,000 to one million dry metric tonnes of tailings a year include permanent geobag storage in their options assessment. The technology offers a practical way to dewater, contain and progressively store suitable tailings without creating a separate cake-handling operation.

Include the work after filtration

A useful comparison follows the same incoming tailings stream through to its final stored condition. A filtration-only operating rate stops too early. The filter produces cake; the project must still get that cake into an appropriately formed and managed stack.

Published research recognises this distinction. Carneiro and Fourie's Western Australian conceptual study included transport, spreading, moisture conditioning and compaction. It used A$3.65/t for placement, with a consultant alternative of A$1/t, for a hypothetical 2 Mtpa operation and a 1 km haul. Annual maintenance, labour and administration were excluded on an assumed-similar basis. The lesson is to examine what a quoted rate includes, rather than assume every published total covers the same work. [1]

SRK describes fully compacted dewatered stacks as continuing earthmoving operations whose operating costs can exceed those of the dewatering plant. Its discussion also shows how structural and non-structural zones can change the required compaction effort. The placement allowance should follow the proposed deposition design. [2]

Geobags installed in their permanent position combine dewatering and deposition. Solids accumulate inside the unit while water drains out; separate transport and compaction of filter cake are avoided. That benefit belongs in the comparison alongside the bag purchase. Temporary dewatering followed by excavation or relocation is a different arrangement and should include its subsequent handling costs. [3, 7]

A competitive operating comparison

The following Australian-dollar example excludes GST. The bag inputs are Kontain's proposed budgeting allowances for suitable heavy tailings: A$7/dmt for supply and A$2.50/dmt for deployment and connections. Bag purchase prices increase with unit size; the A$7/dmt allowance therefore stays constant across the selected payload range. Filtration at A$4/dmt and placement at A$6/dmt are editable comparison inputs.

Selected operating costGeobag storageMechanically filtered stack
Bag supply per dry tonne storedA$7.00/dmt—
Bag deployment and connectionsA$2.50/dmt—
Filtration including process power, operators and routine maintenance—A$4.00/dmt
Loading, transport, conditioning, spreading and compaction as required—A$6.00/dmt
Selected subtotalA$9.50/dmtA$10.00/dmt

These are selected operating subtotals. Capital, storage pads, lining, drainage, polymer and closure sit outside this table. Bag pumping, excavator use, dosing and routine filling support must also be included wherever they are additional. Filtration power, operators and routine maintenance are already inside the filtration allowance and should not be added again.

The placement break-even is A$5.50/dmt. Across an A$5–7/dmt placement range, the mechanical subtotal is A$9–11/dmt, placing the A$9.50 bag case firmly in the competitive range before capital differences. The A$6 midpoint is a planning allowance to replace with the site's haul route and placement requirements.

The historical A$3.65/t placement assumption, if treated as a 2018 dry-tonne rate, becomes approximately A$4.83–5.00/dmt when indexed to September 2026 using the ABS Other Heavy and Civil Engineering Construction series. This is useful cost context rather than a contractor quotation: the original rate's precise price base and dry-tonne interpretation are assumptions in that escalation. [1, 4]

A more relevant throughput reference than a very large mine is WSP's 2026 Peruvian study. Its first stage processes 1,500 dmt/day for 360 days, or approximately 540,000 dmt/year. Estimated filtration OPEX is US$2.51/t, including electricity, operating personnel and maintenance. Loading and an 8.6 km truck haul add US$4.75/t, bringing the reported subtotal to US$7.26/t. Initial filtration-plant capital is separately estimated at US$20.79 million. [5]

These are Peruvian estimates in US dollars, with a substantial haul distance; they are not Australian quotations. They nevertheless demonstrate the importance of pricing the complete route. The loading-and-haul increment should not be assumed to include every subsequent conditioning and compaction activity.

Labour should follow the work

Geobag deployment and connections are periodic tasks. A shared site crew can install the next units, connect lines and return to other work between activities. Filling management and inspections remain part of the operating plan. Mechanical systems likewise require operators and maintenance support, plus the people and equipment involved in their placement route.

The calculator allows either measured deployment hours or a manual A$2.50/dmt allowance. For context, four people at A$100 per person-hour working eight hours on a 1,000-dmt bag cost A$3.20/dmt before equipment. The A$2.50 allowance corresponds to 6.25 crew-clock hours at that rate and payload. Actual bag size, deployment time and shared duties determine the appropriate input.

At 2,000 dmt per bag, 100,000 dmt/year requires about 50 units annually, or approximately one per week. At 600,000 dmt/year, it requires about 300 units annually, or six per week. This is a manageable planning basis for scheduling deployment, filling and drainage within an engineered pad layout. Bag supply remains A$7/dmt in the example as the unit price scales with capacity.

Separate shared infrastructure from real differences

For an initial comparison between two dewatered stacks, a common allowance for site preparation, lining, water management and closure is reasonable where the proposed designs have similar requirements. Equal costs cancel from the decision; they should not appear against bags while disappearing from the filtered alternative.

The quantities are established from matched concept layouts. Comparable external slopes help, while stack height, dry density, inter-bag voids, access and foundation conditions determine the actual footprint. The same discipline applies to polymer: retain common upstream costs in both routes and identify any additional conditioning dose separately.

This makes the comparison easier to understand. Bag supply and deployment are placed against filtration and cake placement, while real differences in pads, pumps, plant, drainage and closure remain visible. Neither route is burdened with a cost simply because its estimate happens to show more detail.

Capital matters more when there are fewer tonnes

Small operations have fewer tonnes over which to recover installed capital. Every additional A$1 million committed to one route relative to another, spread over five years, contributes:

Annual tailings productionLifetime dry tonnesAdditional capital per dry tonne
100,000 dmt/year500,000 dmtA$2.00/dmt
600,000 dmt/year3,000,000 dmtA$0.33/dmt
1,000,000 dmt/year5,000,000 dmtA$0.20/dmt

This simple allocation excludes financing, discounting and residual value. It explains why the capital difference can matter more than a small difference in operating rates. Bag purchases can follow production, allowing expenditure to grow with the stored inventory and reducing reliance on a large initial mechanical installation.

Wet-storage facilities can also be developed in stages, and a filter plant may serve a long mine life. A fair cashflow comparison therefore uses the actual construction sequence, operating life and spare capacity. Three- and five-year storage stages are useful planning scenarios, rather than universal limits on TSF development.

Wet storage has a substantial construction cost

A TSF raise benefits from an existing facility; a new storage development may need foundations, roads, drainage and water infrastructure from the outset. Divide each cost by the usable dry capacity that expenditure creates. Annual mine production and storage volume in cubic metres are different denominators.

For a published Australian example, Aeris reported A$17.3 million for a Cracow TSF upgrade adding approximately one million cubic metres and around three years of production capacity. That is A$17.30/m³. At an assumed dry density of 1.4 dmt/m³, the equivalent is A$12.36/dmt of added capacity; a project-specific dry density is required for the conversion. This was an expansion, not a new facility. [6]

Kontain's discussions with mine operators also include stage allowances around A$10–15/dmt and markedly higher new-facility costs. Two confidential Australian examples were reported at approximately A$45 million for two million dmt and A$30 million for one million dmt: A$22.50/dmt and A$30/dmt respectively. These are operator-reported cost-and-capacity pairs, retained anonymously as project context rather than published market benchmarks.

Construction cost is only one part of wet storage. Deposition, water return, monitoring, maintenance and closure also belong in the whole-life estimate. At the same time, published studies contain lower-cost wet-storage options. The commercial case for bags is strongest when it is established from the site's actual alternatives, rather than a universal dam rate.

Operational benefits beyond the rate per tonne

Geobags offer a simpler process at the storage location. Pumping and filling pressure initiate drainage, followed by continued water release and consolidation under gravity, self-weight and subsequent loading. Each bag performs its dewatering function without a continuously operating mechanical press. This reduces the mechanical equipment associated with the dewatering step, while pumping and dosing duties remain straightforward items to cost. [3, 7]

Enclosing the tailings suppresses dust from the stored fines and avoids dust-generating cake transfer and placement activities where the bags remain in position. The fabric provides continuing surface containment as the material dries. Normal road, spill and later excavation controls still apply, but the exposed tailings surface is fundamentally different from an open stack. [8]

Bag geometry and surface containment also reduce direct rainfall exposure and can limit rewetting compared with loose, exposed material. Rain sheds from the curved surface, while the contained solids retain their position. The fabric is permeable, so this advantage works with a graded pad and effective drainage; it is not a waterproof barrier. Australian geotextile-tube experience reports reduced direct rewetting, supporting this practical benefit. [9]

An exposed filtered stack must accommodate rainfall, changing moisture and trafficability through its deposition and stormwater design. Depending on the material and climate, this can involve conditioning, working-area management and compaction. Some designs use uncompacted zones, so the allowance should follow the design rather than a blanket rule. [10]

For future reuse, identifiable bag cells can keep dewatered material accessible and segregated. That can support recovery planning without relying on an active wet impoundment. Opening bags, removing fabric and any subsequent processing are then costed as part of the recovery operation.

Manage risk through controlled filling and smaller inventories

Geobags change the form and distribution of the stored material. Dewatering reduces mobile water, while separate units divide the incoming slurry inventory into smaller compartments. This is an important distinction from retaining a large connected inventory of water and wet tailings. It gives designers a more localised initial loss-of-containment scenario to manage.

During filling, the operating procedure sets maximum fill height and pressure, controlled flow and clear stop criteria. The system design can specify overflow, pressure-relief or automatic shutdown arrangements to provide further protection. These are practical safeguards against overfilling, supported by inspection of connections, fabric and seams. Overfilling is an operating condition to control, not an inherent reason to reject the method. [3]

As drainage and consolidation progress, the material becomes less mobile and behaves increasingly as a contained soil mass rather than pumped slurry. A fabric defect in a consolidated unit is therefore a different event from a failure during filling. The design still considers erosion, local release and interaction between units; neither the likelihood nor the consequences of every possible event can be reduced to a single bag without considering the stack as a whole. [7]

Foundation performance, overall stability, drainage and closure remain normal engineering responsibilities. The advantage is a storage arrangement with reduced mobile-water inventory and defined operating units, rather than a claim of zero risk. That provides a sound basis for comparing consequence, inspection and maintenance requirements alongside cost.

Work through the comparison with Kontain

For suitable tailings at smaller mines, geobags can combine competitive cost with simpler dewatering, less handling, dust suppression and progressive expenditure. Their value becomes clear when the comparison includes the work required to deliver the final stored material, rather than stopping at the outlet of a filter.

Kontain's Tailings Cost Comparison tool is free to use through our website. We strongly recommend a presentation and a guided comparison with Kontain before relying on the results for a project decision. The calculation is straightforward; choosing consistent payload, labour, plant, placement and storage inputs requires knowledge of the proposed operation.

We can work with the mine's technical and operating teams to establish those inputs, compare the complete alternatives and identify the site information needed for a useful estimate. The tool remains freely available for users who already understand their inputs and want to explore their own scenarios.

Use the free calculator on the Kontain website: https://kontainsolutions.com/tailings-cost-comparison/

Arrange a presentation and guided project comparison with Kontain: https://kontainsolutions.com/request-quote

Sources and calculation basis

[1] Carneiro A and Fourie AB 2018. A conceptual cost comparison of alternative tailings disposal strategies in Western Australia. Paste 2018, pp. 442, 446–447 and 451. https://papers.acg.uwa.edu.au/d/1805_36_Carneiro/36_Carneiro.pdf

[2] Norambuena Mardones RE, Caldwell-Crystal C and Cobos D 2023. How high is too high? Challenges on the next generation of dewatered tailings stacks. Paste 2023, pp. 468–469. https://papers.acg.uwa.edu.au/d/2355_35_Norambuena/35_Norambuena.pdf

[3] Assinder PJ, Breytenbach M, Wiemers J and Hörtkorn F. Utilizing geotextile tubes to extend the life of a Tailings Storage Facility. HUESKER and SRK, sections 4.2 and 5. https://www.huesker.com.au/fileadmin/media/Scientific_Revised_Paper/P761_Utilizing_geotextile_tubes_to_extend_the_life_of_a_Tailings_Storage_Facility_.pdf

[4] Australian Bureau of Statistics. Producer Price Indexes Australia September 2026, Table 17, series A85220823L. The escalation assumes a 2018 price base and dry-tonne interpretation. https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/economy/price-indexes-and-inflation/producer-price-indexes-australia/sep-2026/6427017.xlsx

[5] Gonzales G and Huillca G 2026. Detailed engineering for the implementation of filtered tailings in Peruvian underground mining. WSP, Paste 2026, pp. 9–10. Costs retained in US dollars. https://papers.acg.uwa.edu.au/d/2655_13_Gonzales/13_Gonzales.pdf

[6] Aeris Resources 2024. Annual Report, pp. 2 and 10. https://aerisresources.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Aeris_AR_2024_WEB.pdf

[7] da Silva F 2023. Stacked deposits of thickened and filtered fluid fine tailings using geotextile tubes concepts and lessons learned updates. Paste 2023, pp. 640–645 and 649. https://papers.acg.uwa.edu.au/d/2355_49_da_Silva/49_da_Silva.pdf

[8] Solmax. GEOTUBE Dewatering for Mining and Mineral Processing, APAC brochure, p. 5. https://geofabrics.co/sites/default/files/2024-07/GEOTUBE_Dewatering_for_mining_and_mineral_processing_APAC_1123_Web(1).pdf

[9] Smith M 2009. Geotextile tubes in environmental applications. Australian Geomechanics Society Sydney Chapter Symposium, pp. 110 and 119. https://geomechanics.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/K-Smith-paper.pdf

[10] BHP and Rio Tinto Tailings Management Consortium 2026. Unlocking Large Tonnage Filtered Tailings Stacks A Geotechnical Perspective, March, pp. 12 and 24. https://www.bhp.com/-/media/project/bhp1ip/bhp-com-en/documents/sustainability/tailings-storage-facilities/260508_whitepaperfilteredstacks.pdf