A COMMON BASIS FOR A BETTER DECISION

Compare the costs
that change.

Geobags combine dewatering and final placement. For mines producing 100,000–1 million dry tonnes a year, avoiding separate cake handling can make them highly competitive. Compare bag supply and labour with filtration and placement, then work through the full project costs.

Illustrative inputs · replace with site dataAUD excluding GST · dmt = dry metric tonne
FREE TO USE · REVIEW IT WITH KONTAIN

Get the inputs right with your project team.

We recommend a Kontain-led comparison and presentation before using the results for a project decision. We can help define usable capacity, deployment productivity, storage layout and what each quoted rate includes. The calculator remains free to explore yourself.

ANNUAL TAILINGS
SUGGESTED INPUTS · APPLY ONLY WHAT YOU NEEDStart from an example, then use your site data.

Selecting an example only previews it. Apply buttons change the named inputs; your annual tonnes, project life and other allowances stay as entered. The Full project view shows the resulting cost basis.

THE OPERATING COSTS THAT DIFFER

Two routes. Five assumptions.

Selected operating costs only — not total project cost. Both routes still need appropriate storage, water management and closure.

EDIT THE COMPARISON

Use your rates.

A$/dmt · before capital

Filtration is an operating-cost allowance including power, operators and maintenance. It excludes plant capital. The A$4/dmt starting value is an illustrative input. Full project starts with the same operating allowance and adds separate plant capital, reagents, placement and storage; an alternative capital-inclusive contract mode is also available. See a published 540,000 dmt/year filtration study ↗ for scale and scope context; it does not establish this A$4 rate.

PLACEMENT IS THE SWING FACTOR

Test the handling rate.

Positive difference means the selected geobag operating costs are lower. Negative means the selected mechanical operating costs are lower.

KEEP THE BOUNDARY FAIR

Shared costs cancel only if equal.

Civils, lining, polymer and closure are held equal in this focused comparison. That is an assumption to check, not a claim that the costs are identical.

Use adjustments below for real route-specific differences, including bag pumping, supervision, maintenance or extra handling. Avoid adding filtration power, operators or maintenance a second time.

OPTIONAL ADJUSTMENTSAdd real operating or capital differences

Enter only additional route-specific costs. Zero means no allowance has been entered; it does not prove that the cost is zero. Capital is spread across the entered lifetime dry tonnes without discounting or contingency.

Need the complete picture? Use Full project for storage stages, activity-based labour, plant capital, operating coverage, closure and cashflow. Its separate assumptions change only when you edit them or explicitly apply an example to both models.

Test a specific operating case. Apply a manual bag-labour allowance and volume-based mechanical placement cost. All other assumptions stay as entered.

THE COMPARISON

Three routes. One cost boundary.

Illustrative model outputs, not supplier quotations or a recommendation.

COST DRIVERS

What is included?

Undiscounted lifetime cost divided by actual dry tonnes stored. Unused final-stage capacity is paid for.

GEOBAG OPERATIONS

Labour follows the work.

A crew is charged for deployment and connections. Routine operating cover is counted separately.

COMPARE THE SAME SCOPE

Energy, labour and placement.

Component rates before any additional model contingency. Standalone energy calculations show the entered kWh/dmt × energy price; a bundled or contracted energy component is not separately known and is not added again.

WHEN YOU PAY

Capital timing matters.

GeobagsMechanicalWet storage

Undiscounted cash costs in constant AUD. Year 0 funds the first operating year. Later year boundaries combine that year's operating costs with capital ready for the next year. Contract-rate mechanical processing assumes payment per dmt and no upfront plant payment.

View annual cashflow table
SCALE CHECK

Change throughput. Keep the constraints.

Same inputs and project life; additional storage stages and complete bags are purchased as needed. Productivity does not improve automatically. These are fixed stage designs, not optimised designs for each production rate.

Re-size cells and dam stages for fair new-site quotations: a large unused stage can dominate a small operation's result. Throughput does not validate process capacity, drainage, working area, stack geometry or approvals.

TURN A SCREENING RESULT INTO A DECISION

Measure the assumptions that move the answer.

Use representative tailings trials to confirm captured dry mass per bag, elapsed deployment hours, polymer dose, drainage time and final condition. Then compare itemised contractor and equipment quotations on the same scope.

MAKE THE MODEL YOURS

Only compare what you can explain.

Changes calculate immediately

Starting values are examples. Bag supply at A$7/dmt, manual labour at A$2.50/dmt, filtration operation at A$4/dmt and placement at A$6/dmt follow the concept inputs. The starting wet-storage quote is the mine-reported A$45m / 2m-dmt example; its cost-capacity pair is not publicly verified. The stage-allowance dropdown offers an editable A$12.50/dmt capacity assumption. Other populated costs are demonstration allowances. Replace them with measured rates, scoped quotations and an engineered storage layout.

Keep the starting feed and storage endpoint equivalent. A processing service rate must say whether it covers plant capital, operators, reagents, energy and maintenance. Zero means no cost has been allowed.

A CASE THAT CAN BE SCRUTINISED

The practical case for geobags.

01

Dewater and store in place

Permanent bags receive the tailings where they will remain. This removes the separate filter-cake loading, haulage, spreading and compaction sequence from that storage route.

Include any planned relocation or later recovery as a separate activity.
02

Suppress dust and direct rewetting

Enclosing the solids suppresses dust from stored fines. Tube geometry and the contained filter cake reduce direct rainfall exposure compared with loose, exposed tailings.

Permeable fabric works with drainage and water management; it is not a waterproof cover.
03

Simple passive drainage

Pumping fills the bags; drainage and consolidation continue without a mechanical press at each unit. This simplifies the dewatering process and reduces the machinery requiring continuous attention.

Use the actual pumping and dosing duty when estimating energy and operating costs.
04

Spend progressively

Bag supply follows production. Smaller mines can expand storage progressively, limit the initial processing investment and retain identifiable dewatered material for future recovery.

Keep pad development, supply lead times and eventual recovery costs in the project plan.
KONTAIN TECHNICAL ARTICLE

Why geobags deserve a place in the smaller-mine comparison

Explore the cost of final placement, the operational benefits of contained dewatering and the different risk mechanisms behind each storage route.

Read the article →
AUSTRALIAN CONTEXT

Published storage costs are project-specific.

A dam construction cost per tonne of capacity is not a complete lifecycle storage cost. Scope, price date, dry density, remaining life and closure obligations all matter.

Source notes are being loaded.

HOW THE NUMBERS WORK

A transparent calculation.

Dry tonnes first

Lifetime production = annual dry tonnes × project years. A dry tonne measures solids mass, not a moisture-free product. Wet tonnes, slurry volume and tonnes of ore are different quantities. Bag supply defaults to an A$/dmt rate. An optional per-bag quotation uses verified dry payload and whole-bag rounding. Payload remains an operational input for deployment workload.

Labour is an activity

Deployment labour = complete bags × crew-clock hours per bag × people per crew × hourly rate. Roster mode charges the allocated roster instead. Manual mode uses the entered A$/dmt allowance while retaining the activity and crew-capacity checks. Routine operating labour is added separately.

Storage capacity has a cost

Storage stages = lifetime tonnes ÷ stage capacity, rounded up. Each full stage cost is paid when it is needed, or all at the start if selected. The last stage is paid in full even when only partly used.

Timing is visible

Undiscounted cost = total cash cost ÷ total dry tonnes. Discounted levelised cost = present value of costs ÷ present value of tonnes, using the selected real discount rate. It is a screening comparison, not investment advice.

One mechanical cost basis

Operating-bundle mode covers power, operators and routine maintenance, while plant capital, reagents, placement and storage remain separate. Contract-service mode includes process capital recovery and operation in a paid-per-dmt rate, with no upfront plant payment. Detailed mode itemises plant operation. Included components are never added twice.

No automatic upside

The model does not credit tailings sales, recovered water, avoided failures or future metal recovery. Test those opportunities separately using actual specifications, recovery costs and agreements.

FROM SCREENING TO A SCOPED COMPARISON

Build the comparison with Kontain.

Use your operating data

Bring your tailings properties, dry-tonnage schedule, bag payloads and deployment records. Kontain can help translate these into labour, polymer, pumping, drainage and storage inputs for a consistent comparison.

Review the facility together

Obtain geotechnical and permitted stack layouts, working-area and drainage requirements, and site quotations for civils and lining. Match mechanical and wet-storage quotations to the same feed, final condition, closure and monitoring scope.

Define the product first

If reuse is the goal, specify moisture, chemistry, particle size and handling properties. Drier is not automatically more valuable. Include opening, excavation, fabric removal and further treatment before estimating revenue or water credits.

Scope and limitations

This is an early-stage cost screening tool. Costs are in Australian dollars excluding GST, with a constant real price basis. It does not design a tailings facility, prove dewaterability, certify stack stability or establish regulatory acceptance. Life is modelled in whole years at constant annual throughput. Check earthworks measurement, liner coverage, access, drainage, redundancy, environmental monitoring, long-term closure and post-closure liabilities before relying on a result.

Kontain supplies geobags and has a commercial interest in their use. Alternatives are included to support a fair, project-specific comparison. Neither bags nor mechanical filtration are assumed to be cheaper in every application.